Quick Summary
Windsurf
An AI-enhanced IDE offering intelligent code suggestions, collaborative tools, and advanced project management capabilities.
Rating:
4.5/5
AI Code Review Action
An AI-powered GitHub Action designed to automate code reviews, generate comments, and provide feedback on pull requests.
Rating:
3.5/5
Tool Overview
1st
Windsurf
Agentic AI Assistant
2nd
AI Code Review Action
AI Code Review Assistant
Features
Features
| Feature | Windsurf | AI Code Review Action |
|---|---|---|
| Subtype | IDE | GitHub Action |
| Recommendation | Recommended | Ignore |
| Privacy | Contextual Data Encryption | — |
| AI Model Support | Limited AI model options | — |
| Collaboration | Real-time team collaboration with intelligent assistance | — |
| Terminal Integration | Direct command execution via chat | — |
| Code Checkpoints | Simplified reversion with checkpoint system | — |
| Integration with GitHub Actions | — | Seamless integration into GitHub workflows for automated code reviews |
| GPT-3.5 Turbo Model | — | Uses the GPT-3.5 Turbo model for analyzing and generating code feedback |
| Line-by-Line Review | — | Provides detailed feedback on pull request changes |
| Duplicate Comment Reduction | — | Minimizes duplicate and redundant feedback comments |
Pricing
Pricing Plans
| Plan | Windsurf | AI Code Review Action |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 Basic access with limited features | $0 Basic automated code review capabilities |
| Pro | $18/month Advanced AI model integration and collaboration tools | $15/month Enhanced comment management and priority processing |
| Enterprise | Custom Scalable solutions for large teams | Custom Scalable workflows and advanced integrations |
Pros & Cons
Windsurf
Pros
- •Deep contextual understanding of codebases
- •Powerful Cascade Technology for task automation
- •Real-time collaboration features
- •Strong terminal integration
Cons
- •Limited support for diverse AI models
- •Advanced features require familiarization
- •High resource consumption for large projects
AI Code Review Action
Pros
- •Easy integration into GitHub workflows
- •Automated pull request reviews
- •Context-aware line-by-line comments
Cons
- •Generates redundant comments
- •Struggles with larger code diffs
- •Overwhelming volume of feedback
Our Recommendation
Based on the comparison above, we recommend Windsurf for most users because:
- Best overall feature set
- Competitive pricing
- Strong user ratings